The Round Table (Rational Pagans Forum)

Science & The Supernatural: A Discussion of the World Around us - Based on Science with an Interest in the Supernatural ...
It is currently 18 Jun 2018, 00:59

All times are UTC - 5 hours

Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 2 posts ] 
Author Message
PostPosted: 06 Nov 2010, 23:58 
Grand Poobah
User avatar

Joined: 18 Sep 2007, 11:26
Posts: 5793
Location: Buffalo, NY ... _mine.html
Most events called "psychic" do not take place at all, but only seem to. All the events we can perceive take place in a rational universe governed by physical laws. They can be explained by human thinking and do not require a supernatural loophole.

I'm drawn to this thinking by Clint Eastwood's new film, "Hereafter." You may have absorbed the idea that it's about the afterlife. It would be fairer to say it's about the common human need for there to be an afterlife.

When I write that I expect to experience no more after death than I experienced before birth, I receive comments from people who pity me. They wonder how I can possibly live with such a bleak prospect.

I find it more cheerful than most of the other possibilities that have been floated. I don't want to come back as an insect, haunt unquiet places as a ghost, or gaze down benevolently on my loved ones below as they, and all their generations to the end of time, die from mayhem or disease. I am also offered the possibility that I will be absorbed in God's love for all eternity, which is a better offer, but lacking in definition. If that means what it seems to mean, and if God is infinite (as he must be), then the role played by "me" can hardly be aware or conscious in any meaningful way. But I will become part of the universal, you say? I already am. You, too.

There is, however, one form of immortality that is guaranteed, if unrewarding. We certainly live on indefinitely in our constituent atoms, which will be recombined in dust, flowers, trees, the wind, other living beings, and eventually in cosmic stardust.

"Hereafter" centers on a man named George Lonegan (Matt Damon) who believes he has a real psychic gift (he calls it a curse). When he touches another person's hands, there is a jolt and sudden flash, and he becomes a conduit to that person's loved ones in the afterlife. He transmits their messages for the living. Often these messages are uncanny in the private knowledge they contain. George at one point had a web site and a wide reputation, but could no longer endure the burden of his séances; he has gone into construction work and shuns all psychic activities. The film is about his reluctant agreement to act as a medium for a few people, including a small boy who desperately longs for his twin.

It would indeed be a curse if you could read minds. A familiar theme in science fiction is a person tortured by the minds of those around him in the city -- by their fear, terror, remorse. In Salmon Rushdie's Midnight's Children, the hero finds he can telepathically communicate with all the children born at the moment of Indian independence. He convenes them regularly in his mind. This he does with such suspicious ease, I believe, because Rushdie's novel is not about telepathy but about India. The mind-reading device does him no favors, however, and the novel loses its life and urgency when he resorts to it.

If a person could really read your mind or foretell your future, should they charge for it? As Eastwood's movie makes clear, most psychics are frauds, in it for the money. But what if one in a hundred, or a million, was the real thing? "Hereafter" suggests that George might be such a person. That singular person would, I suggest, be driven stark mad soon after birth. But if the gift could be controlled -- say, by acting only when hands are held -- that would allow some degree of mental order. (The prospect of being able to read the mind of a partner during sex is as horrifying as having your own mind read at such a time.)

Let us assume George has a gift. That he tells people things he has no way of knowing. Is Eastwood saying he's truly reading minds? Yes, then he would be. But is he communicating with the dead? Close attention to the film reveals that Eastwood and his writer, Peter Morgan, don't make that claim. They never say concretely what does happen, although something does. Believers will assume George talks with the dead. That is not the only possibility.

Here I'm not, however, going to fall back on the theories of skeptics like James Randi and say George is an unusually intuitive person who picks up vibes and combines them in a Sherlockian manner with cues from clothes, accents, casual remarks and feedback. We all do that all the time. We meet a new person and arrive at instant notions of who they are, what they're like and how they're thinking. Are we correct? You know you do this. Judge for yourself.

I believe it possible that telepathy in some inchoate form can exist. I think it very unlikely, but that's not today's subject. I believe it's possible that communication can take place between two physical minds in a physical universe, with the supernatural not involved. I believe it possible that some few people may be able to inspire heightened transmission from another mind by touching hands or otherwise supplying a psychic jolt. That the "medium" receives images and and personal information of great importance from other people. And that the psychic then repeats back to those people what they desire to hear.

Neither the psychic nor the subject would necessarily be aware this is happening. That would explain why so few communications from beyond the grave are morose or terrifying. Dead spirits never tell us, "I died miserably and am in torment, and you face the same fate." That isn't what we want to hear, and therefore wouldn't be what we transmitted. Indeed, every living person in "Hereafter" receives uplifting information. (Some of it, the film suggests, is knowingly created by George as an act of mercy.)

To be clear: I think this is very highly unlikely indeed. But the more we learn of quantum matters, the slower we must be in declaring things impossible. If the scenario I suggest is possible, actual dead spirits and an afterlife are not necessary. The whole transaction takes place here in the rational universe, using a process we don't understand and may never understand. Not understanding something is not a good reason to declare it supernatural.

There is of course a loophole in my reasoning. What if telepathy, as I suspect, is completely impossible? Yet still a psychic communicates private information he has no way of knowing? Doesn't that require a supernatural level? Not necessarily. Storefront fortune tellers communicate such information all the time. How do they do it?

Typically, they begin with a "Barnum Statement," named after P. T. Barnum, who said "A circus should have something for everybody." For example, they might tell you: "Disciplined and self-controlled outside, you tend to be worrisome and insecure inside. At times you have serious doubts as to whether you have made the right decision or done the right thing. You prefer a certain amount of change and variety and become dissatisfied when hemmed in by restrictions and limitations." Is that true of you? It's certainly true of me. And it was true of every single subject of a famous experiment made by a psychologist named Bertram Forer, cited in this invaluable link.

The link is to a report in Skeptical Enquiry, which argues that Rorschach inkblot tests are simply a form of fortune-telling. It continues by analyzing a typical psychic reading:

"After being warmed up with Barnum statements, most clients relax and begin to respond with nonverbal feedback, such as nods and smiles. In most psychic readings, there arrives a moment when the client begins to 'work' for the reader, actively supplying information and providing clarifications. It's at this critical juncture that a skillful cold reader puts new stratagems into action, such as the technique called the 'push.' A psychic using the push begins by making a specific prediction (even though it may miss the mark), then allows feedback from the client to transform the prediction into something that appears astoundingly accurate."
The article observes that many psychics are sincerely convinced they have a real gift. I'm sure that's possible. I believe they may have exceptionally well-developed empathy and sensitivity, and do actually pick up "vibes." Their readings may be beneficial, as any attention and sympathy from another person is beneficial. An analyst using a Rorschach test may also be sincere, and may obtain valuable psychological information. But the information has come from the client, and not from woo-woo floating in the aether. That would be consistent with my other theory about telepathy: In one way of another, we read our own minds.

It's my guess that "Hereafter" reflects the beliefs of Clint Eastwood and Peter Morgan that such is the case. Of course they don't come out and say so, because their film is not about whether psychics are frauds, or whether there is an afterlife. It is, gently, warmly, kindly, about how we desperately desire for there to be an afterlife. George, the Matt Damon character, is a good and honest man. He isn't a genuine psychic, but he doesn't know that. He's real enough to himself and to the people he helps. There is positive therapy to be found in the process of going through a healing process, whether or not it's based on reality. He helps people. They feel helped.

Eastwood sees those people with a great deal of love: The woman whose life is transformed by the tragedy in the opening scenes. The man who loved his wife and feels he can't carry on without her. The cooking student with dark inner fears. The little boy who misses his dead twin brother. They all need to know that life is not as bleak as it seems. They need to believe those they loved still survive in some form. These are needs as long as the history of Man.

In my opinion, there is no solace for these needs. We live, we die. That is not a tragedy. The tragedy would be never having been born. The number of possible lives that have never been lived is so large that actual lives represent a vanishingly small number after a decimal point and a great many zeros. We won a cosmic lottery by being not only alive but being self-aware and able to think rationally. That is cause for joy. We should collect our winnings and feel grateful when we die.

But we are humans, poor, frail, fearful, hopeful. We seek solace. I believe "Hereafter" understands that. It is a deeper and more subtle film than many will realize. In my review, I deliberately avoided any mention of Clint Eastwood's age. Some reviews suggested he made this film because he's getting older, and his thoughts turned to mortality. That is condescending. Our thoughts turn to mortality every day, as is natural. The important thing is that Eastwood's thoughts didn't turn to immortality. The stories in his film take place entirely on this side of the grave, as all stories must.

Chloride and Sodium: Two terribly dangerous substances that taste great together!

PostPosted: 26 May 2016, 04:37 

Joined: 26 May 2016, 03:44
Posts: 84
<P>lmx omega watches My burberry outlet scalp houston rockets jerseys a first tiffany und co glance, jordan retro almost gucci handbags in front burberry outlet online of tommy hilfiger online a burberry black lakers jerseys man phoenix suns jersey to nike free run fight new balance canada back gucci shoes outlet is northface crazy knife, milwaukee bucks jersey all giuseppe zanotti sneakers of ralph lauren a polo ralph lauren outlet online sudden it lions jerseys hit giants jerseys the roshe run lights into a root, jimmy choo shoes immediately vans outlet extinguished, surrounded north face by kate spade handbags a dark eagles jerseys picture lululemon australia becomes, reebok followed coach outlet online by vans shoes my ferragamo shoes hand Nike Shoes was tory burch wrapped mcm bags around michael kors outlet what louboutin shoes to nike shoes outlet live, roshe run hard jaguars jerseys to chanel sunglasses twist dre beats back, nike schoenen I michael kors outlet online sale was pandora charms scared ed hardy clothing completely ralph lauren outlet online lost minnesota timberwolves jersey the long champ ability ugg to think, tiffany and co howl tory burch outlet loudly, michael kors bags exhausted detroit pistons body nike shoes strength polo ralph lauren outlet to nike air force think hermes bags over timberland femme with nfl jerseys a insanity workout calendar struggle, air max the body bottega veneta following new balance a cheap oakley not completely wholesale clothing click, huarache click ghd horny asics roots louboutin I uggs sank levis jeans the whole person, yoga pants and things together free running behind tory burch shoes me fell into tommy hilfiger a ray ban outlet shallow pit michael kors outlet inside.</P>
<P>I nike roshe fall hollister at the same jordans time, I heard coach outlet someone nike air max call adidas superstar out: air jordan retro "You're a Shuaigui!" atlanta hawks jerseys Then prada outlet flashlight thomas sabo uk lit ralph lauren up, mcm backpack outlet while cheap ray ban firmly pressing my gucci shoes boss prada sunglasses Wang, ralph lauren outlet while shining woolrich jackets his ralph lauren polo flashlight oakley sunglasses outlet into wedding dresses my chicago bulls jersey eyes christian louboutin shone new york knicks almost converse sneakers blind canada gooses outlet a. hogan outlet I was coach outlet canada about to michael kors outlet online hand oakley sunglasses outlet to seahawks jerseys cover, patriots jerseys dumped coach outlet online suddenly nike shoes gave him ugg a glasses online slap oakley vault in bengals jerseys the oakley sungalsses outlet face, uggs on sale there nike air max is ray ban wayfarer no nike free 5.0 strength browns jerseys left, my harrods london nose is now a pandora cold ray ban start nosebleeds.</P>
<P>I vikings jerseys kick michael kors canada him after ugg boots clearance he timberland boots severely air max scolded michael kors me chanel bags a barbour outlet few swarovski crystal times, roshe run and nike free 5.0 said:. rolex watches "You toms shoes outlet a dolphins jerseys Pujie golden state warriors jersey Aberdeen, purses and handbags you do michael kors bags not ugg boots wanna give ray ban sonnenbrillen you wedding dress face, burberry outlet and hilfiger online shop I soccer shoes juggle swarovski australia fat guy, uggs you toms shoes go mcm handbags to hell."</P>
<P>I tommy hilfiger outlet immediately realized utah jazz jersey that it ray ban outlet was new orleans pelicans jersey all long champ about huarache how coach factory his mother hogan to ray-ban sunglasses death in michael kors outlet Guangdong juicy couture handbags this gucci mens shoes fat jimmy choo outlet actually tiffany and co has nike free 5.0 the supra footwear guts uggs outlet to michael kors outlet online sale come secretly to iphone case touch, ferragamo look rams jerseys at this air max shoes person is longchamp taschen probably michael kors not ray ban occhiali the reaction michael kors outlet online I michael kors outlet thought I was azcardinals jerseys in adidas canada with handbags outlet him oakley sunglasses juggle, ralph lauren factory store and tiffany jewelry I polo outlet store taboo reloj inside, oklahoma city thunder jersey afraid memphis grizzlies jersey to go m a c cosmetics after michael kors me toms shoes outlet with ralph lauren polos a hollister kids word, coach outlet did salvatore ferragamo not ralph lauren even adidas superstar open the jets jerseys flashlight, secretly beats headphones climbed steelers jerseys in, I pandora was being ugg run into the air jordan ghost cheap oakley dance beats headphones listen michael kors handbags to ugg australia the babyliss pro sound, pandora canada the nike air max result swarovski online was air max schoenen almost counterassaulted colts jerseys give ugg boots me instyler ionic styler a ralph lauren outlet knife burberry outlet to chi hair do, michael kors outlet online and polo ralph now ray ban wayfarer probably nike shoes outlet thought I wanted nike air max 90 to nike air max kill coach purses outlet online he.</P>
<P>I would michael kors uk like to orlando magic jersey explain, softball bats but his pandora schmuck card with my ralph lauren outlet online neck, hollisterco I could longchamp handbags not boots on sale speak. swarovski jewelry He seemed oakley canada unbearable prada anger, but also beats by dre a mcm backpack outlet slap in nike schuhe the longchamp outlet face sacramento kings jersey and packers jerseys hit my nike roshe ears north face backpacks hum hermes is heard, san antonio spurs jerseys I burberry online shop suddenly fire abercrombie and fitch kids from saints jerseys the burberry outlet heart, the rayban heart that I fuck coach factory your michael kors canada grandmother, oakley dare valentino outlet hit shows puma outlet did baseball jerseys not raiders jerseys even nfl jerseys look nike air max at veneta me buccaneers jerseys as christian louboutin shoes a person, immediately true religion outlet on a adidas online hit true religion jeans in puma online the mont blanc past, he will marc by marc jacobs hit a supra footwear strong, oakley sunglasses cheap two people broncos jerseys roll lululemon together, moncler mens jackets you new balance blow moncler outlet online my cheap basketball shoes foot, portland trail blazers jersey all michael kors of toms outlet a adidas online sudden timberland shoes the burberry outlet online coffin brooklyn nets jerseys rolled slit celine bags edge polo ralph of zapatillas nike his ralph lauren outlet strength ravens jerseys than salomon schuhe me, hermes belt all coach outlet store online of longchamp a chargers jerseys sudden they cleveland cavaliers have montre homme the philadelphia 76ers jerseys upper bears jerseys hand, ralph lauren outlet I mizuno wave put mcm backpack pressure michael kors handbags on chi flat iron the body, gucci I air max 2015 looked washington wizards jersey up tory burch and burberry handbags wanted to hollister online pinch michael kors the thomas sabo result here michael jordan too nba jerseys short, bills jerseys lift nike mercurial vapor his replica watches head, polo ralph lauren hit abercrombie on falcons jerseys one michael kors v?skor of michael kors usa the marc by marc jacobs roots, ugg boots he indoor soccer shoes knocked michael kors purses the coach outlet online moment, I cheap oakley sunglasses suddenly tommy hilfiger outlet stores took coach factory outlet the lunette ray ban opportunity to ray bans kick his panthers jerseys crotch the north face at oakley sunglasses the top vans schuhe of prada outlet the new balance he katespade Dingfan p90x out, heat jerseys then nike roshe rushed gucci uk grabbed the north face outlet his fossil uhren flashlight cheap nfl jerseys into his head that straightener moment, michael kors taschen he oakley will hit Mongolia coco chanel in cheap coach purses the air huarache past.</P>
<P>I hollister clothing store pressed on ugg boots him north face to see if nike shop he is new balance outlet temporarily north face outlet unable to oakley vault move, juicy couture outlet use baseball bats a burberry sale flashlight to glasses frames shine around wedding dresses and saw nike tn this omega watches bird equipment and los angeles clippers jersey gun red bottom shoes did not bring oakley sunglasses in, presumably toms shoes feel the north face inside prada shoes too narrow 49ers jerseys escape gucci outlet fear timberland outlet hurt redskins jerseys yourself. mac makeup I calvin klein underwear touch purses and handbags him, nike shoes wanted to burberry outlet online take his chanel handbags dagger, rolex watch he would abercrombie suddenly abercrombie fitch I watches canada was converse outlet up ray ban sunglasses one, and rayban I like knockoff handbags him, ray bans one gafas oakley hit kate spade outlet online the cowboys jerseys top, rolex watches for sale driven northface to burberry outlet store see asics gel stars, air max quickly turn coach outlet store to tiffany and co one replica watches side, nike air max thea so oakley outlet give denver nuggets jerseys him burberry sale the top a coach outlet store online bit. nike huarache I toronto raptors jersey have toms outlet online brains coach outlet online out cheap true religion from the nose.</P>
<P>Wang burberry sale boss swarovski jewelry to titans jerseys get up, louboutin shoes who ray ban sunglasses outlet are all canada gooses fine pandora bracelet roots cheap michael kors and must nike store be bcbg max azria crushed iphone 5s cases fungi, tommy hilfiger already air jordan shoes angry face christian louboutin shoes twisted texans jerseys up, charlotte hornets jerseys breathing adidas superstar heavily, his eyes converse shoes are chiefs jerseys red, boston celtics jersey I nike outlet know toms shoes he bebe clothing moved dallas mavericks jerseys Murder, prom dresses like ray ban zonnebril him the north face that coach bags kinds ralph lauren outlet of punks giuseppe shoes started to climb beats by dr dre step swarovski by step air max to north face jackets the nike air max people, gucci belts to jordan release dates 2015 kill true religion jeans outlet certainly michael kors outlet online sale heavy, and always abercrombie kids wanted mcm backpack to ralph lauren kill bcbg max each lululemon canada other. coach factory outlet It rolex seems tiffany and co australia this yoga pants time, really barbour factory want converse chucks a hollister clothing fight to longchamp outlet the bitter.</P> indiana pacers jersey

Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 2 posts ] 

All times are UTC - 5 hours

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 7 guests

You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum

Search for:
Jump to:  
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group