The Round Table (Rational Pagans Forum)

Science & The Supernatural: A Discussion of the World Around us - Based on Science with an Interest in the Supernatural ...
It is currently 22 Oct 2017, 21:25

All times are UTC - 5 hours


Forum rules


Please note: Discussion here should be relatively civil. Attack the post, not the poster. Thanks!



Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 3 posts ] 
Author Message
PostPosted: 14 Oct 2010, 12:41 
Offline
Grand Poobah
User avatar

Joined: 18 Sep 2007, 11:26
Posts: 5793
Location: Buffalo, NY
interesting report. Lotsa hyperlinks and pics at the link.

http://shethought.com/2010/10/14/beam-m ... bbit-hole/

Quote:
Beam Me Down the Rabbit Hole
By Nicole Gugliucci, on October 14th, 2010


On October 9th, 2010, I went down the rabbit hole. I went to a Mutual UFO Network conference.

The Setup
First, I’ll admit something that I haven’t talked about all that much. I once believed that aliens were visiting Earth and that there was a government cover-up. I wasn’t always so skeptical. I was, and still am, quite gullible and willing to give people the benefit of the doubt. There were several reasons for my interest in UFOs. When I was 13, we got the internet mainly for me to use for academic purposes as I started high school. In addition to deepening my interest in astronomy, I discovered the UFO culture. Possibly, getting my own television helped, for I stumbled upon the hotness that is David Duchovny and started watching The X-Files. I would watch provocative paranormal shows like Sightings on the Sci-Fi channel and eat it all up. I quietly stayed up past my bedtime to listen to Art Bell, and I freaked the heck out reading Whitley Strieber’s Communion as if it was factual. I wished to see a UFO myself but I never did, despite many hours attempting to be an amateur astronomer under the light-polluted Staten Island skies. At some point, I don’t remember exactly when or why, I yearned for better evidence and lost interest in UFOs. Additionally, conspiracy theorists were quite wrong about Y2K, and they simply made me angry when the first 9/11 conspiracies cropped up. Though I had yet to be introduced to a truly skeptical view of the subject, I simply “lost the faith.”


I do, however, remain a "Shipper" to this day.
Fast-forward to today, where I entertain the much more plausible explanations of the UFO phenomenon, from Carl Sagan’s Demon-Haunted World to Skeptic magazine. Yet, the UFO phenomenon is still fascinating to me as an astronomer, as someone who has been emotionally impacted upon meeting alleged abductees, and as someone who damn well wishes that we make contact with intelligent extraterrestrials in my lifetime. So, as a project for the Independent Investigations Group in DC, and out of sheer curiosity, my skeptical pal Brian Gregory and I set out for the Philadelphia MUFON conference this past weekend. What follows is a summary and description as best as I can write. Surely, I’ve missed something important, or mangled some memory, or neglected to follow up on an important point. For that, I apologize, and hope to follow up on my notes from the conference as time allows.

General Impressions
I had never really interacted with other believers in “meatspace” at the time I was pro-aliens-are-here, so this was to be a learning experience for me. I got out of a warm bed with an even warmer Tim at 7am on a Saturday morning to drive up to Bucks County and get there in time for registration and the first talk. The meeting room at the Sheraton was filled with nearly 200 people, so I’d say that is pretty sizable for a local meeting, especially compared to similar skeptics’ meetings. Overall, the day started off interesting, but ended up rather frustrating. I think that by the end of the say I reached the limit of logical fallacies and misused scientific terms that I can handle in one day.

I tried to tune in when skeptics were specifically mentioned by the speakers. The term “skeptic” was used interchangeably with the term “debunker” to point out where skeptics were wrong, too cynical or closed-minded. This suggests the distinctions stressed by James Randi, Joe Nickell, and others are not influential in this crowd. In one instance, CSICOP co-founder Philip Klass was singled out as having been factually wrong about the Hill case (though I haven’t been able to verify that). Certainly, skeptical treatments of the subject are not perfectly accurate, but singling out of this incident indicates an inherent distrust of all things skeptical, and also stressed to me the importance of scholarship in skepticism to reduce the capability of believers to cherry-pick mistakes.


Those skeptics just don't accept the evidence
I noticed some odd similarities to a skeptical conference. The speakers seemed very much displeased with their treatment in the media. There were several complaints of bias, of ridicule, and of poor reporting. Skeptics are generally not happy with gullible reporting in the media and the false notion of “balance.” So, neither group feels they are getting a fair shake. Many UFO believers also found it hard to “come out” to their family and friends, or had their interests ridiculed. More than a few skeptics have complained about the same. Finally, typical for any niche community, they had their own assumptions and “in-jokes,” of which Brian and I were fairly clueless. We must have had n00b written all over us!

The prevalence of logical fallacies, anomaly hunting, and other altogether human critical thinking pitfalls were not concepts I directly picked up in my early observations of the UFO community, but they are obvious to me now. Many proponent concluded, “I can’t explain it, therefore it must be unexplainable, or at least fantastic,” whether it was crop circles, claims related to the Betty and Barney Hill abduction case, or just in defining the field in general. A clear appeal to authority was used where the testimonies of pilots, especially from the military, were considered unassailable. They thought it laughable that pilots could be mistaken in what they see, though in reality, no one is immune to faulty perception. However, other authorities, such as the UN’s “ET ambassador” were labeled unreliable. (“She’s an astrophysicist. Does she know anything about the subject?”) Examples of anomaly hunting could be seen in the attention to minute details in “elongated nodes” and “expulsion cavities” at crop circle sites. We saw a video of researchers collecting armfuls of wheat, yet only a handful of samples were shown in the results.


I really do miss this show.
The overall feeling was that *something* weird is going on, and *someone* is hiding the truth about it. They express a strong desire for “disclosure.” Though the focus may shift from lights in the sky to abductions, from spirituality to fear, from grand conspiracies to personal experiences, there was an underlying belief that at least some UFOs go beyond mundane explanation, and that the truth will soon come out.

Specific Talks
John Ventre, MUFON director for Pennsylvania, did the introduction. He was also there promoting his new book, 12/21/2012: A Prophecy, which, of course, rubs me the wrong way. (FWIW, it is presented as fiction, and, who knows, may be better than that garbage movie.) He covered several local and recent UFO news items, including the National Press Club announcement and the supposed UN ambassador to ET. It was here that some of the speakers expressed their displeasure, as some felt that such an ambassador should come from their community instead. There was no mention that this story was totally mistaken, or that the SETI community had been claiming that role for some time. In any case, I decided that it would be best to keep mum that I, too, am an astrophysicist. (Well, grad student in astronomy. Close enough.)

The first talk was delivered by Karyn Dolan. Host of a paranormal internet radio show, “Through the Keyhole,” she presented the differences and similarities between the study of UFOs and of other paranormal phenomena, such as ghosts and hauntings. This seemed like an attempt to bridge a gap between two fields that don’t always get along, but which she described as both being “beyond understanding.” Although she initially (and correctly) identified UFOs as simply things in the sky that were unidentified, and that there was actually no presupposed claim as to what they are, the very next slide defined ufology as the study of the crafts and the beings that pilot them! So, “unexplained” was narrowed down to “intelligently piloted craft” in just one slide.

However, putting aside the blatant assumptions about the paranormal reality of UFOs and ghosts, it was particularly interesting to see the comparison of UFO abduction experiences with haunting experiences. One is cold and impersonal while the other is personal and human. One is from “elsewhere” and the other is local. One is physical and the other “non-physical.” Yet, both are “beyond understanding.” She even pointed out the hypothesis, first popularized by John Keel and Jacques Vallée, that faeries and demons of the past are the same thing as ghosts and aliens in the present. Interestingly, I agree with that, but not in the way that she would think. Instead, I suspect that they are the same effects of the human psyche that have been with us all along, just shaped by time and culture. She seemed to argue, however, that these past and present phenomena were external and real.


Kathleen Marden
Next up was Kathleen Marden, niece of Barney and Betty Hill, the now infamous first case of alleged alien abduction. I was particularly interested in this since I had used details of this case in my “Life Beyond Earth” class at the University of Virginia. Marden was obviously convinced of their abduction account, as she co-authored a book on it with Stanton Friedman. She was just 13 when the event occurred, and heard the Hills’ stories as they told it to her mother, Betty’s sister. Most of the accounts were derived from hypnosis sessions that the Hills began over two years after the alleged event. Their experiences with a weird sighting of lights in the sky, health problems, and bad dreams turned into the landmark abduction story that seems to have spawned countless others. The American Psychological Association does not support the validity of most supposed repressed memories, as can be tragically demonstrated in far too many false accounts of child abuse.

Marden pointed out many instances where the hypnotic session of each matched, but neglected to show where they did not match, such as how Betty heard them speak English while Barney thought they communicated telepathically. Nor do I remember her ever saying that the hypnotist, Dr. Benjamin Simon, decided in the end that the memories were not real. She did, however, note the glaring difference between the human-like abductors in Betty’s dreams and the archetypal “greys” that they described in the hypnosis sessions. The unreliable results of hypnosis and recovered memories likely did not reflect reality, so that throws out most of the first-hand accounts, though the audio may be emotionally moving. After undergoing hypnosis, the Hills really believed that they had been abducted and experimented upon, as do the few abductees with whom I’ve spoken while in New Mexico. The suffering is almost palpable, but the real cause is likely not extraterrestrial or inter-dimensional. Betty’s torn, 40-year-old dress is not convincing, and neither is the alleged star map, though my astronomical curiosity will likely lead me towards a second look.

After lunch, we were late for the talk by Bill Birnes about History Channel’s UFO Hunters, since the hotel restaurant clearly underestimated how many people would show up for a UFO conference and was severely understaffed. And, they overcooked the ahi tuna. Shame! Anyway… the talk by Birnes was really hard to follow with no visuals and, as far as I could tell, no thread to tie it together. It was story after factoid after report after name… I’m really at a loss to describe it. I was tempted to ask his opinion on the Morristown UFO sighting, which he claimed was definitely “real,” yet hoaxers confessed not too long after. However, I didn’t want to “out” myself so early in the day. He did offer his “three landing legs” of evidence for UFOs being a serious phenomenon, and I admit, I appreciate the metaphor. The evidence, however, was not convincing, consisting of boat-loads of eyewitness accounts (the plural of anecdote is not evidence), a “path of legitimacy” in government documents (which don’t seem to offer any “proof” other than usual security concerns), and physical trace evidence (which doesn’t seem to be enough to convince scientists.)


Evidence for the paranormal, or meaningless anomalies?
Next was the talk that really blew my brain wide open. It was a very well-crafted talk by Jen Stein, crop circle researcher. Heavy on the jargon, she showed examples of “elongated nodes” in flattened crops and “expulsion cavities.” The working hypothesis of cereology seems to be that some sort of microwave-like effect bursts the water out of wheat stems. Only a few examples of “control” and flattened crops were shown to have these characteristics which made me wonder how rigorous their collection methods and statistics really are. Although it is clear to Stein that some crop formations are man-made, the idea that all crop circles are perpetrated by humans was simply unbelievable to her. Never mind that they blatantly showcase their work, or that crop circle enthusiasts often can’t tell the difference between a “real” and “fake” formation.

But that wasn’t the head-asplodey part. I finally had my breakdown when she got into the possible explanation for crop circles. They were not man-made, nor were they the artistic works of ET. Instead, they were caused by ionospheric disturbances. What followed was such an awful mangling of scientific concepts that I had to rest my poor head on Brian’s shoulder for support. I don’t fault Stein specifically for repeating the hypotheses put forth by others, and I can’t fault her for misunderstanding scientific terms. But someone in the cereology community managed to amass just enough knowledge about physics, or at least physics jargon, to come up with this mishmash and display it as science, and that is disheartening to a scientist and educator. Especially one whose thesis relates directly to ionospheric disturbances. The “iono-speric plasma’s” were caused by x-rays spiraling around magnetic field lines and producing electrons and strengthening the magnetic field and being drawn to certain sites in England…. Oh, it was just a mess. (FWIW, electrons spiral around magnetic field lines and produce photons across the electromagnetic spectrum, and also slam into the atmosphere creating aurora. Not frakking vortices.)


Cool kids sit up front
We stuck it out for one more talk about the “national security state” and the world “after disclosure” by Richard Dolan. He has written several books on what he believes is a huge conspiracy, mostly by private interests but with some government influence, to cover up ET crashes, landings, beings, and technologies. Though he gave brief mention to abductions and the spiritual aspect of close encounters, his focus was clearly on the political and economic motivations, and was highly speculative. Although he claimed that there is a paper trail of military interest in UFOs, his list certainly seems to thin out significantly after the 1960s, when the Air Force determined in Project Blue Book that the UFO phenomenon was no longer worth investigating. He crafted a compelling story, but to me, it was just a story. Perhaps he was just here to sell books, but I really do think he passionately believes that some monumental change is coming in our society, and it will involve the disclosure of the UFO secret in the coming decades. At one point, I experienced what Daniel Loxton has called “skeptical vertigo.” I lost my grip on my skepticism and thought, “oh my goodness, what if it’s all TRUE?” My worldview would certainly be shaken if a cover-up of this magnitude really was in play, and just for a moment I was transported to a universe where this was true. It was pretty scary, and that, I think, is what finally broke my brain for the day.


OM NOM NOM
However… there was one more mind-bending experience yet to be had. The conference was followed up by a performance by a band called the Bambikillers. Ventre had allowed them to play, though he didn’t know anything about them other than the fact that at least one band member was a MUFON member. I was particularly excited to see an all-girl punk band rock out about aliens, but what actually happened topped off the day in a way that I thought only happens in sitcoms. It was just bizarre. Despite the hot, spacey outfits, their “playing” was terrible! I imagined George Hrab’s head exploding somewhere in Texas as the drummer eeked out a boring rhythm and the singer tried to waver her voice. If you want to experience some of the badness, do check out Brian’s video. But beware, your little punk soul will cry out in agony. Of course, it wasn’t just one song. Oh no, it was a whole set and performance piece. Once they started crawling over each other, eating fake human body parts smeared in fake (I hope) blood, we made a beeline for the hotel bar. Needless to say, the other conference attendees and presenters were not impressed and, in some cases, were outwardly annoyed. Live and learn, I guess!

Lessons Learned
After I sufficiently recovered, I could finally begin to organize my thoughts about this conference. I expected a learning experience, and I certainly got one. My “rabbit-hole” feeling reminded me that it is not too unreasonable for someone to slip into a belief like this, especially one not armed with skeptical tools, as I was so unarmed at 13. These people believed, experienced, and formed a community around a fringe belief, and still are going strong after so many years. I don’t expect them to be dissuaded any time soon.

Interestingly, we also discovered that MUFON members can become investigators once they join by studying a rather thick manual and being tested on it. A very helpful gentleman explained this to us, and said he was about to start his first case. Clearly, MUFON has set itself up as the go-to organization for people who have had sightings or experiences. Since they are so well-established, it is going to be difficult for skeptical and scientific investigators to get their foot in that door.

Although the logical fallacies hurt my brain, I do not hold that these people are crazy or lying. They seem curious, sometimes suspicious, and overwhelmingly honest about their beliefs. Most speakers were intelligent, well-spoken, kind, and generous with their time in the lobby. There is a sense of comfort and community in being with fellow believers. Though many may never be swayed by skeptical arguments, I worry more for those in the middle, neither believers nor skeptics, that see these claims and start to get sucked in by the story. And for that, we need to know what these claims are and why people make them. This experience was just a taste of that for me, and though in some ways it scared me, it also renewed my interest in investigating the phenomenon, only this time with a scientific frame of mind.

_________________
Chloride and Sodium: Two terribly dangerous substances that taste great together!


Top
 Profile  
 
PostPosted: 09 Dec 2016, 02:39 
Offline
Adherent

Joined: 09 Dec 2016, 00:53
Posts: 80
<P>basket uggs of mcm handbags fish. chiefs nfl jersey But cheap clothes they wedding dresses did swarovski jewelry not saints nfl jersey go oakley canada our michael kors purses separate vans ways, insanity workout but coach black friday agreed juicy couture outlet to ray ban outlet online work timberland boots together uggs on sale to phoenix suns find vans shoes the tory burch outlet sea, givenchy handbags They adidas online only pandora cook bengals nfl jersey a longchamp outlet fish michael kors handbags each cheap oakley sunglasses time coach factory online they ray bans travel lions nfl jersey through ralph lauren black friday the orlando magic jersey distant, nike came ralph lauren polos to broncos nfl jersey the true religion jeans men beach, burberry sale then mcm bags the celine black friday two giuseppe shoes began new balance shoes a timberland outlet day michael kors black friday of burberry outlet store fishing, occhiali ray ban a horloges few baseball bats years polo ralph after, nike roche run they oakley vault built nike air max 2014 a hogan outlet house, with soccer shoes their mcm bags respective dsquared2 jeans families, uggs on sale children air max have ralph lauren their rams nfl jersey own swarovski crystal fishing omega boats canada gooses built, converse shoes and jordans lived hogan a adidas outlet happy michael kors handbags and tommy hilfiger peaceful dolphins nfl jersey life.A burberry handbags outlet person plein outlet only buccaneers nfl jersey the hollister immediate nike air yeezy interests will burberry handbags eventually kate spade outlet online get lunette oakley the oakley vault joy air max was uggs black friday short-lived; cheap michael kors a aktienkurse adidas goal nike air huarache will lunette ray ban be ray ban black friday high, prada handbags but bears nfl jersey we iphone 5 cases must ray ban outlet face cheap mlb jerseys the adidas outlet reality rolex watches of jordans life, barbour jackets only hilfiger outlet the rockets jersey ideal nba jersey and occhiali oakley reality nike air max combine converse it thomas sabo be prada outlet possible ugg to coach handbags become nike a coach factory outlet online successful cheap glasses person.We marc jacobs often lacoste outlet online times nike of tory burch handbags difficulties, polo ralph lauren even oakley sunglasses to ray ban wayfarer the levi's jeans critical nike.com moment, knockoff handbags suddenly ugg boots someone air max else's air jordan retro help, toms outlet we michael kors black friday like michael kors handbags straw oakley sunglasses caught ray bans in watches canada the north face storm, ferragamo shoes like ed hardy clinging kobe bryant jerseys to wizards jersey hold ray ban sunglasses nothing omega watches to abercrombie kids consider, redskins nfl jersey despite abercrombie everything babyliss pro , cheap barbour jackets and pandora schmuck desperately, cheap michael kors grasp texans nfl jersey it longchamp black friday firmly, salvatore ferragamo on pandora charms hand, cowboys nfl jersey while mizuno running ignoring uggs the michael kors handbags thought, golden state warriors jerseys like polo ralph lauren outlet online accidentally adidas than nba jersey not nike roshe swim burberry outlet online out chi flat iron of burberry the celine bags water, swarovski canada desperately knicks jersey struggling tommy hilfiger in mcm handbags the toms shoes water, jets nfl jersey into coach outlet the fake rolex water philadelphia 76ers jerseys to ray ban outlet save new orleans pelicans him kings jersey if jaguars nfl jersey someone, prada shoes he uggs outlet will replica rolex firmly converse grasp ray ban this swarovski online person, fossil uhren and cheap nike shoes this louboutin result coach handbags outlet is jazz jersey that armani shoes outlet this ralph lauren polo is pandora jewelry to cheap jerseys save air max one people chargers nfl jersey who oakley black friday grasped him ralph lauren outlet firmly, cheap true religion but hollister do denver nuggets jersey not nike mercurial put nike hands ray-ban sunglasses and feet north face backpacks open, nfl jerseys lose nike roshe the hollister co ability beats audio to ralph lauren swim, new balance so michael kors outlet that hilfiger outlet two longchamp people tory burch handbags are coach outlet canada not ravens nfl jersey out barbour jackets water.Of canada gooses outlet course, coach black friday we roshe runs do mcm handbags outlet not toms shoes outlet mean nike free to burberry outlet save, charlotte hornets jerseys not michael kors taschen to north face say converse sneakers pretended long champ not air jordans to see, hugo boss clothes we calvin klein underwear need nike shoes the ralph lauren outlet online wisdom handbags outlet of clippers jersey the coach handbags mind, instyler to coach outlet online make oakley sunglasses outlet the five finger shoes right ralph lauren judgments, dre beats no air max 2015 matter barbour outlet online how ugg boots difficult adidas canada things, nike air max I cheap oakley believe coach purses factory that burberry handbags outlet the mbt mens shoes principle swarovski of ugg australia the method kate spade outlet online is nba jerseys better michael kors bags than hilfiger online shop more burberry sale difficult, air force the michael kors use air max of raptors jersey intelligence, tommy hilfiger hyperactivity polo ralph lauren brains, oakley rather tommy hilfiger than longchamp handbags blindly north face thirst michael kors handbags to coach bags see michael kors whether omega watches or nike huaraches not hermes direct adidas used uggs to use, giants nfl jersey and louboutin outlet then air max 90 there beats by dr dre is nike outlet a michael kors outlet problem, oakley sunglasses outlet we ray ban sunglasses outlet need red bottoms to ralph lauren factory store look oakley at cheap oakley sunglasses whether salomon remembered true religion outlet what discount shoes circumstances, puma online but northface this north face jackets time has nike been pandora uk too michael kors late.Just cartier montres before michael kors bags the new balance outlet two ralph lauren hungry nike air max people abercrombie.com in prada sunglasses the ralph lauren outlet online story true religion jeans women told, roshe only 49ers nfl jersey to valentino meet longchamp outlet their cheap nhl jerseys own barbour jackets for basketball shoes a ray ban short versace clothes while, brooklyn nets jersey without replica rolex considering hollister the nike air max other, jimmy choo shoes he mont blanc was eagles nfl jersey thirty pacers jersey tube ugg boots clearance XXI softball bats she longchamp had colts nfl jersey to moncler jackets outlet eat, new balance canada or true religion that cheap michael kors he michael kors purses can patriots nfl jersey have coach store fishing cheap mlb jerseys tool burberry sale on roshe run the cheap true religion line, kevin durant jersey day michael kors outlet online to ralph lauren online shop day, boston celtics whether red bottom shoes it toms shoes be uggs after adidas it, thomas sabo we indoor soccer shoes feel san antonio spurs jersey sad ipad mini cases for air max 90 them, huarache while michael kors in cheap jerseys fact north face outlet in michaelkors.com which juicy couture we p90x live, oakley sunglasses we giuseppe zanotti sneakers sometimes chaussure timberland are coach outlet sale the michael kors same, vans there longchamp is fendi bags no polo ralph lauren outlet long-term bcbg max azria goal, hollisterco not burberry handbags lofty michael kors ideals, jordan and free run just timberland shoes goof nike canada today the north face outlet gone, ray ban tomorrow eyeglasses stores is ray ban outlet another woolrich mens jackets day, beats by dr dre life puma sneakers is ray ban sonnenbrillen short, the north face had browns nfl jersey finished azcardinals nfl jersey today, nike free run although moncler jackets it cheap jerseys will handbags outlet come http://www.nba-shoes.com/ tomorrow, panthers nfl jersey but ferragamo today oakley sunglasses outlet we louboutin uk have ugg to steelers nfl jersey come michael kors bags back burberry who tory burch shoes can bucks jersey save asics gel it.Years supra shoes of reebok age falcons nfl jersey a swarovski jewelry man, nike air max 2014 time asics waits ray ban for pandora no toms shoes one, cheap oakley sunglasses although ray ban sunglasses outlet we uggs outlet can katespade not hollister kids change cheap nhl jerseys the dallas mavericks jerseys length abercrombie and fitch kids of ralph lauren outlet online life, ugg but abercrombie fitch can dwyane wade jersey try marc jacobs to north face change michael kors the jimmy choo outlet width packers nfl jersey of oakley sunglasses cheap life cheap jordans Yeah! jerseys from china Full oakley day, straightener a guess outlet online day prada wasted nike outlet effort designer handbags is nike outlet store the tn pas cher day bills nfl jersey ill bottega veneta spent hermes bags a air jordan shoes day, veneta the nike free run 5.0 pain grizzlies jersey is nike Air Max Plaza day, titans nfl jersey happy cheap ray ban day, nike shoes outlet overcast rolex replica day, jordan jerseys bright toms shoes day, new balance why cavaliers jerseys can kate spade bags not burberry sale we hollister have hermes birkin bag lived michael kors outlet online up toms.com to vikings nfl jersey it's coach store online wonderful!Own ugg way, coach factory outlet no seahawks nfl jersey one toms shoes outlet for michael kors canada us to chi hair go, trail blazers jersey their timberwolves jersey pain, ralph lauren online and louboutin outlet no bcbg max one raiders nfl jersey for ralph lauren uk us christian louboutin shoes points, atlanta hawks jersey </P> burberry


Top
 Profile  
 
PostPosted: 27 Mar 2017, 04:22 
Offline
First Circle Initiate

Joined: 27 Mar 2017, 03:16
Posts: 173
Interview with Jinfeng reebok is not my knockoff handbags intention. nike roche run I went to cheap jordans visit nike Air Max Plaza her, michael kors purses completely out polo ralph lauren outlet online of respect toms shoes outlet for her, and chrome hearts store want to ask her. rolex watches Though, roshe we are not new orleans pelicans familiar nike free run with.But, coach outlet online together wedding dresses with the cheap mlb jerseys easy tn pas cher and frank michael kors black friday conversation for denver nuggets jersey a ralph lauren polos few atlanta hawks jersey hours, ed hardy I not only benefit from, orlando magic jersey but burberry outlet also that coach factory outlet do not write anything, omega so that dre beats readers toms outlet can cheap nhl jerseys friends and eyeglasses stores I michael kors bags share my nike air max harvest and happiness."Reporter pandora always in polo ralph lauren outlet the eagles nfl jersey answer" after prada outlet the cheap oakley news, redskins nfl jersey I timberland outlet gave Jinfeng teacher rushed toms shoes outlet to polo ralph lauren write coach handbags a new balance letter, and coach factory attached nba jersey to the converse shoes two newspapers. air max 90 Soon ralph lauren outlet after lunette oakley receiving cheap nhl jerseys her coach outlet sale reply -Come nike back swarovski jewelry from the north face outlet Tianjin dsquared2 outlet and bears nfl jersey receive northface your jordan jerseys letter and clippings. barbour jackets Did michael kors canada not michael kors purses think, casually talk, tory burch handbags you oakley sunglasses actually longchamp sorted out. The coach outlet canada young man louboutin outlet is quick and the thought is pandora liberated. swarovski canada ... ... raiders nfl jersey you mcm handbags are omega watches working golden age, energetic, responsive, will long champ be titans nfl jersey able dolphins nfl jersey to louboutin uk contribute lacoste outlet online to michael kors the seahawks nfl jersey cause burberry of softball bats journalism. Chinese women celine black friday journalists replica rolex are not nike a lot, falcons nfl jersey we longchamp outlet need mcm handbags to occhiali ray ban live fake rolex up christian louboutin to browns nfl jersey their vans own, do bcbg max azria a barbour outlet online good job.ow cordial, how hollister sincere, this michael kors purses discourse nike air max is barbour jackets like my converse old sister trail blazers jersey from kate spade outlet online the mouth coach factory online of cheap oakley sunglasses the oakley money burberry sale out. burberry handbags Although in ray ban the new balance outlet family I hogan outlet did barbour jackets not michael kors taschen old sister, but ralph lauren I believe that juicy couture if coach handbags there is, she rockets jersey will polo ralph lauren be adidas outlet like ferragamo shoes Jinfeng. So, I tommy hilfiger hurried indoor soccer shoes to burberry sale mention burberry handbags outlet the pen back michael kors to a rolex replica letter, mbt mens shoes how adidas to write the michael kors letter, I have not ray ban sunglasses remember.Once nike air max 2014 again received baseball bats Jinfeng's reply, is replica rolex still ray ban sunglasses outlet so nike tracksuits cordial, hermes bags so coach store online sincere, like nike the azcardinals nfl jersey old oakley sunglasses sister's jordans letter levi's jeans -Received your warm jimmy choo shoes letter, kids hoodies read chaussure timberland me nike free run 5.0 touched, ashamed kate spade outlet online and uneasy. nike air max 2014 Through the lines oakley vault between omega watches the hermes lines, prada shoes I seem fossil uhren to louboutin see you ralph lauren outlet online love the news discount shoes work designer handbags of adidas online a colts nfl jersey beating louboutin outlet heart. News longchamp outlet work swarovski online is a hilfiger online shop very bengals nfl jersey difficult phoenix suns but aktienkurse adidas proud burberry handbags outlet work, north face jackets especially longchamp black friday the world dsquared2 jeans into the information age, cheap barbour jackets as ecco outlet online an marc jacobs important tool for mizuno running the basketball shoes transmission roshe runs of information nike mercurial work, mcm bags the times bucks jersey have mcm bags given us cheap ray ban a grizzlies jersey greater responsibility. Therefore, although nike I have been nike canada 56 years coach store old, cheap glasses in this nike air yeezy post ray-ban sunglasses just coach handbags outlet fighting air max for giants nfl jersey 35 years, five finger shoes but pandora schmuck will cheap mlb jerseys do my spare oakley heat, fighting in michael kors outlet online this post down.See ray ban sonnenbrillen here, air max my heart is hot. Dry journalists calvin klein underwear for many under armour curry years, there have polo ralph been tommy hilfiger many ups and nike.com downs, oakley but patriots nfl jersey I supra shoes still cheap jerseys infatuated, boston celtics why? golden state warriors jerseys Jinfeng's answer, timberland boots it is nike roshe my north face answer.Did michael kors not expect chargers nfl jersey this cartier montres report hilfiger outlet soon lunette ray ban reported, I jimmy choo outlet also coach outlet online received cheap michael kors another coach outlet woman's burberry letter. coach store outlet A nike outlet 40-year-old nike air max woman who salomon did celine bags not ray ban black friday know the salvatore ferragamo letter. With a curious jordans heart, I will michael kors come to the buccaneers nfl jersey letter tory burch shoes slowly pandora charms -You valentino do prada handbags not timberwolves jersey know wizards jersey me, and ray bans I ralph lauren uk have long nike shoes outlet from kevin durant jersey the "Jiangxi Daily" adidas outlet on tommy hilfiger the air max 90 "know" ralph lauren you. Say "know", just plein outlet know that oakley sunglasses cheap you are a longchamp newspaper new balance shoes reporter, burberry often reported in michael kors outlet online the pacers jersey province michael kors of nike outlet store some major news, pandora uk guess air max you michael kors outlet online sale have a free run certain beats by dr dre political instyler status. tommy hilfiger As handbags outlet for beats audio the new balance other, such nike shoes as your experience, people, coach bags and iphone 5 cases even gender, age is ignorant michael kors handbags (only sometimes from the name converse sneakers of huarache men versace clothes and women). swarovski Did cheap clothes not hollister put you in mind, air max because ralph lauren polo the north face outlet reader air max one is knicks jersey only concerned kings jersey about tory burch outlet the air jordan retro news you marc jacobs reported the air jordans story itself, ray ban wayfarer and ravens nfl jersey will tory burch handbags not oakley sunglasses outlet pay attention burberry handbags to you. ray ban But ray ban sunglasses outlet this babyliss pro time ralph lauren different. April asics 28, red bottom shoes "Jiangxi jordan Daily" mcm handbags outlet you giuseppe zanotti sneakers wrote the oakley vault "reporter is michael kors handbags always in raptors jersey the armani shoes outlet answer", hollisterco but unexpectedly attracted my special attention. givenchy handbags "Jinfeng" nike air huarache the name michael kors outlet I am puma sneakers very cheap nike shoes familiar with, cavaliers jerseys often chiefs nfl jersey in prada a nike mercurial variety ray bans of nike air max newspapers to see juicy couture outlet her michael kors outlet online article. nike outlet And nba jerseys you burberry sale further elaborated ray ban on her experience, oakley sunglasses family and nike free career, adidas naturally ralph lauren black friday aroused panthers nfl jersey great philadelphia 76ers jerseys interest. You nike roshe read jazz jersey this chi hair article several times, packers nfl jersey and finally came to ralph lauren outlet online a puma online conclusion: saints nfl jersey you, timberland shoes certainly michael kors outlet a cowboys nfl jersey lesbian. You respect Jinfeng, and chi flat iron even coach factory outlet online follow Jinfeng. rams nfl jersey As the ralph lauren outlet online saying goes: katespade "the text ray ban outlet of its ray ban outlet people." Although I have never touched burberry outlet online you, ralph lauren online but the reader jerseys from china to understand ipad mini cases a reporter, to kate spade bags understand oakley canada an texans nfl jersey author air force or burberry outlet store writer, not often nfl jerseys from their articles, air jordan shoes works thomas sabo began? However, I thomas sabo wondered: broncos nfl jersey only this article, I air max 2015 can then "wishful thinking" steelers nfl jersey to imagine hugo boss clothes you new balance canada so pandora jewelry well? cheap true religion I have not touched you michael kors after all. And now the social outlook, michael kors handbags it is burberry sale indeed far adidas less than before, true religion good people north face backpacks less, no, toms shoes precisely, is a ray ban lot veneta of 49ers nfl jersey good people, but brooklyn nets jersey as fendi bags a good cheap jerseys person occhiali oakley should have good cheap jerseys quality, but hogan not dallas mavericks jerseys easy cheap michael kors to be good clippers jersey people coach purses factory often keep ferragamo going. Good people are also twisted, dwyane wade jersey it nba jersey seems difficult swarovski jewelry to watches canada get better, ray ban outlet online so go. red bottoms But in any true religion outlet case, swarovski crystal I lions nfl jersey think christian louboutin shoes we bills nfl jersey should trust you. toms.com Because you michael kors handbags are roshe run engaged north face in http://www.nba-shoes.com/ the true religion jeans men party toms shoes and nike the people of vikings nfl jersey the jaguars nfl jersey journalism, is ralph lauren a bcbg max noble, cheap oakley sunglasses honest people north face can mont blanc engage philipp plein clothing in hilfiger outlet the end adidas canada and cheap true religion do nike huaraches some achievements of a longchamp cause. hollister In this beats by dr dre front, charlotte hornets jerseys pious asics gel people the north face of bottega veneta hypocrisy, jets nfl jersey probably hermes birkin bag difficult longchamp handbags to get coach black friday a lot oakley sunglasses outlet of readers toms shoes welcome ... ...Line michael kors line of giuseppe shoes handsome cheap oakley sunglasses text, a oakley black friday sharp horloges sharp white, so hollister co I nike air force believe ralph lauren outlet that this vans letter hollister kids must ray ban outlet come hollisterco from true religion jeans women a michael kors bags thoughtful learning vans shoes good woolrich mens jackets woman hand. Who ralph lauren online shop is she? What kind of north face unspeakable prada sunglasses she needs to oakley sunglasses outlet talk to people? kobe bryant jerseys I am p90x eager ralph lauren factory store to soccer shoes find handbags outlet an answer from my letter. She kept toms shoes telling me san antonio spurs jersey in the letter converse -


Top
 Profile  
 
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 3 posts ] 

All times are UTC - 5 hours


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum

Search for:
Jump to:  
cron
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group